Preview:

SUPREME COURT OF ARIZONA En Banc THE LOFTS AT FILLMORE CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, an Arizona nonprofit corporation, ) ) ) ) Plaintiff/Appellant, ) ) v. ) ) RELIANCE COMMERCIAL CONSTRUCTION, ) INC., an Arizona corporation, ) ) Defendant/Appellee. ) ) ) ) _________________________________ ) Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-07-0416-PR Court of Appeals Division One No. 1 CA-CV 06-0257 Maricopa County Superior Court No. CV2004-012726

O P I N I O N

Appeal from the Superior Court in Maricopa County The Honorable Kristin C. Hoffman, Judge REVERSED AND REMANDED ________________________________________________________________ Opinion of the Court of Appeals, Division One ___ Ariz. ___, ___ P.3d ___ (2007) VACATED ________________________________________________________________ THORSNES BARTOLOTTA McGUIRE By John F. McGuire, Jr. And EKMARK & EKMARK, L.L.C. Scottsdale By Curtis S. Ekmark Quentin T. Phillips Attorneys for The Lofts at Fillmore Condominium Association BREMER, WHYTE, BROWN & O'MEARA, LLP By Jeffrey D. Holland John J. Belanger Phoenix San Diego, CA

And ISRAEL & GERITY, PLLC By Kyle A. Israel Jeffrey R. Cobb Attorneys for Reliance Commercial Construction, Inc. FEINBERG GRANT MAYFIELD KANEDA & LITT, LLP By Daniel H. Clifford Bruce Mayfield Charles R. Fenton Attorneys for Amicus Curiae Regatta Pointe Condominium Association Phoenix

Phoenix

DICKS, COGLIANESE, LIPSON & SHUQUEM, APC Phoenix By Michael D. Dicks Darrien O. Shuquem Attorneys for Amici Curiae Alta Mesa Resort Village Homeowners Association, Inc.; Bella Vista Condominium Homeowners Association; Villages of Chandler: The Boardwalk Homeowners Association, Inc.; Cave Creek Villas Homeowners Association, Inc.; Kennedy Park Homeowners Association, Inc.; Mona Lisa Village Homeowners Association; Scottsdale Abrivado Condominium Association; The Salado Grand Residential Association, Inc.; Tre Bellavia Homeowners Association, Inc.; and The Village at Carefree Conference Resort Condominium Association, Inc. KASDAN SIMONDS RILEY By Kenneth S. Stephen L. Michael J. Attorneys for Amicus & VAUGHAN, LLP Phoenix Kasdan Weber White Curiae Adobe Villas Condominium Association

ECKLEY & ASSOCIATES, P.C. Phoenix By J. Robert Eckley M. Philip Escolar Attorneys for Amici Curiae National Association of Home Inspectors, Inc. and American Society of Home Inspectors BOROWSKY LAW, P.C. Scottsdale By Lisa M. Borowsky Attorney for Amici Curiae Arizona Consumers Council and Consumer Federation of America

2

KASDAN SIMONDS RILEY By Kenneth S. Stephen L. Michael J. And

& VAUGHAN, LLP Kasdan Weber White

Phoenix

OSBORN MALEDON, P.A. Phoenix By Thomas L. Hudson Attorneys for Amicus Curiae Frye Park Townhomes Homeowner Association ________________________________________________________________ H U R W I T Z, Justice

Download THE LOFTS AT FILLMORE v RELIANCE COMMERCIAL.pdf

Arizona Law