Preview:

RENDERED:

DECEMBER 8, 2000; 10:00 a.m. NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

C ommonwealth O f K entucky C ourt O f A ppeals
1999-CA-001576-MR AND CROSS-APPEAL NO. 1999-CA-001629-MR LEON D. "JOE" BALL APPELLANT/CROSS-APPELLEE NO.

v.

APPEAL AND CROSS-APPEAL FROM WAYNE CIRCUIT COURT HONORABLE EDDIE C. LOVELACE, JUDGE ACTION NO. 95-CI-00116

D. WELDON GREGORY

APPELLEE/CROSS-APPELLANT

OPINION AFFIRMING ** ** ** ** ** BEFORE: BUCKINGHAM, GUIDUGLI, AND MILLER, JUDGES. Leon D. "Joe" Ball brings this appeal and D.

MILLER, JUDGE:

Weldon Gregory brings this cross-appeal from a June 1, 1999, judgment of the Wayne Circuit Court. We affirm.

On November 16, 1858, William Ryan and his wife conveyed to William Dobbs some 190 acres of land which abutted upon the lands of Dobbs already owned. On the same date, William

Ryan and his wife also conveyed to their son, George E. Ryan, seven tracts of acreage located to the south of the acreage conveyed to Dobbs. George E. Ryan recorded his deed on December

6, 1858, and William Dobbs recorded his deed on December 7, 1858.

It was stipulated that Ball's title originated with the deed of conveyance to George E. Ryan recorded on December 6, 1858, and that Gregory's title originated with the deed of conveyance to William Dobbs recorded on December 7, 1858. This dispute arose when Ball allegedly cut timber upon land claimed by Gregory. They both sought quiet title to the

real property, and Gregory also sought damages for the cut timber. On June 1, 1999, the circuit court entered its judgment quieting title in favor of Gregory and awarding $9,544.65, representing the value of the timber cut. This appeal and cross-appeal follow. On direct appeal, Ball contends the circuit court committed reversible error by concluding that his predecessor in title had constructive notice of exceptions in the deed of conveyance. We disagree. Ball's predecessor in title, as In the deed from Ky. R. Civ. P. 39.02.

heretofore mentioned, was George E. Ryan.

William Ryan to George E. Ryan, the following exception was included: The 250 acre survey herein described is subject to the exception and reservation a small peace (sic) included in the deed made to William Dobbs by said Ryan dated the 16th day of Nov. 1858 and also subject to the exception of all interference of the foregoing tracts with any other lands of older and better title. The circuit court concluded that the above exception put Ball's predecessor in title, George E. Ryan, on "constructive notice to inquire as to what the exceptions and interferences (sic) entailed in the way of acreage" in the conveyance. -2Ball,

however, asserts that the exception is void for uncertainty or vagueness. (1931). See Justice v. Justice, 239 Ky. 155, 39 S.W.2d 250 We believe the

We must disagree with Ball's contention.

exception is clear so as to put Ball's predecessor in title on constructive notice. Indeed, the circuit court was able to

determine the proper boundaries of the land in dispute in regard to the exception. As such, we are of the opinion the circuit

court committed no error in ruling that Ball had trespassed upon Gregory's land and consequently awarding Gregory a money judgment against Ball. On cross-appeal, Gregory maintains the circuit court committed reversible error by failing to award triple damages for the timber cut in addition to any legal costs. Statutes (KRS) 364.130(1). Kentucky Revised

The circuit court awarded Gregory the The court

actual value of the cut timber, which was $9,544.65.

reached such conclusion by determining that KRS 364.130(1), which requires triple damages, became effective July 15, 1994, and the evidence failed to establish that the timber was cut after the effective date of the statute. Thus, the court concluded that Gregory counters

Gregory was not entitled to triple damages.

that KRS 364.130(1) should be given retroactive effect as a remedial statute. Gregory, however, fails to direct this court Hence, we are

to persuasive authority for such proposition.

compelled to uphold the circuit court's award for damages. For the foregoing reasons, the judgment of the Wayne Circuit Court is affirmed. ALL CONCUR.

-3-

BRIEFS FOR APPELLANT/CROSSAPPELLEE: Vernon Miniard, Jr. Monticello, Kentucky

BRIEF FOR APPELLEE/CROSSAPPELLANT: Charles C. Adams Somerset, Kentucky

-4-



Download 1999-ca-001576.pdf

Kentucky Law