Preview:

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF MAINE CAMDEN NATIONAL BANK, ) ) PLAINTIFF ) ) v. ) ) WALTER J. SKAYHAN, III, ET AL., ) ) ) DEFENDANTS

CIVIL NO. 09-199-P-H

DECISION AND ORDER ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT On March 1, 2010, I heard oral argument on the plaintiff's motion for summary judgment. Camden National Bank has sued these two individual defendants on their guarantees of the Note of the principal obligor, Maine Investment Properties, LLC. The Bank has moved for summary judgment. It is

undisputed that the defendants signed the guarantees, and that the principal obligor has defaulted. The defendants have resisted the motion only on the basis that damages cannot yet be determined because the Bank has a lien against certain real estate owned by entities related to the principal obligor, and that the real estate may be sold and may ultimately recompense the Bank in part. The motion for summary judgment is GRANTED. The guarantees are

unconditional and do not require the Bank to seek other recourse. This is not

a case of failure to mitigate, unlike the situation before Justice Delahanty in Jerome and Mark Duguay Investments v. Diaz, 1985 Me. Super. LEXIS 209 (July 29, 1985), where he found that the landlord had not taken steps to try to lease the property as to which the principal obligor had defaulted. The

guarantees here are clear that they are "a guaranty of payment and performance and not of collection, so Lender can enforce this Guaranty against Guarantor even when Lender has not exhausted Lender's remedies against anyone else obligated to pay the Indebtedness or against any collateral securing the Indebtedness, this Guaranty or any other guaranty of the Indebtedness." Commercial Guaranty at 1 (Ex. B to Aff. of Stephen Matteo) (Docket Item 18-2). Under the guarantees, the guarantors waived any right to require the Bank to resort for payment against any other person or to proceed against collateral. Id. at 2. SO ORDERED. DATED THIS 8TH DAY OF MARCH, 2010 D. Brock Hornby___________ D. BROCK HORNBY UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

2

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF MAINE (PORTLAND) CIVIL DOCKET NO. 2:09CV199 (DBH) Camden National Bank, Plaintiff Represented By Jennie L. Clegg Daniel L. Rosenthal Marcus, Clegg & Mistretta, P.A. One Canal Plaza, Suite 600 Portland, ME 04101-4102 (207) 828-8000 email: federalcourt@mcm-law.com drosenthal@mcm-law.com

v. Walter J. Skayhan, III and Stephen A. Geppi, Defendants Represented By Randy J. Creswell Perkins Thompson, PA P.O. Box 426 Portland, ME 04112 (207) 774-2635 email: rcreswell@perkinsthompson.com

3



Download DBH_03082010_2-09cv199_CAMDEN_NATL_BANK_V_SKAYHAN.pdf

Maine Law