Find Laws Find Lawyers Free Legal Forms USA State Laws
Laws-info.com » Cases » Washington » Supreme Court of Washington » 1943 » 16 Wn.2d 104, THE STATE OF WASHINGTON on the Relation of Theodore H. Eggers et al., Plaintiff, v. ROGER J. MEAKIM, as Judge of the Superior Court for King County, Respondent
16 Wn.2d 104, THE STATE OF WASHINGTON on the Relation of Theodore H. Eggers et al., Plaintiff, v. ROGER J. MEAKIM, as Judge of the Superior Court for King County, Respondent
State: Washington
Court: Supreme Court
Docket No: 28943.DepartmentTwo
Case Date: 01/06/1943

16 Wn.2d 104, THE STATE OF WASHINGTON on the Relation of Theodore H. Eggers et al., Plaintiff, v. ROGER J. MEAKIM, as Judge of the Superior Court for King County, Respondent

[No. 28943. Department Two.      Supreme Court      January 6, 1943.]

THE STATE OF WASHINGTON on the Relation of
           Theodore H. Eggers et al., Plaintiff, v. ROGER J. MEAKIM,
                    as Judge of the Superior Court for King
                          County, Respondent.1

[1] HABEAS CORPUS - ADOPTION - VACATION - POWER OF COURT. The Superior court has no power or authority summarily to vacate an order of adoption in habeas corpus proceedings, where it appears that, in entering the order of adoption, the court had jurisdiction to make and enter it, and that it and the proceedings upon which it is based are fair and regular on their face.

Certiorari to review an order of the superior court for King county, Meakim, J., entered November 18, 1942, vacating an order of adoption. Reversed.

Ervin F. Dailey, for relators.

John Caughlan, for respondent.

GRADY, J. -

This is an original proceeding in this court, instituted by petition of Theodore H. Eggers and Harriette Eggers, his wife, praying that a Writ of certiorari issue, directed to the respondent, as judge of the superior court of Washington for King county, requiring him to cause to be issued a complete and


1 Reported in 132 P. (2d) 750.

[1] See 25 Am. Jur. 256.

               STATE EX REL. EGGERS v. MEAKIM.          105 
 Jan. 1943]               Opinion Per GRADY, J.

full transcript of the record and proceedings in cause numbered 340010 therein, entitled "In the Matter of the Application of Theodore H. Eggers and Harriette Eggers, his wife, for a Writ of Habeas Corpus," or to show cause, at a time and place to be fixed by this court, why he should not do so. The writ was sought for the purpose of reviewing before this court an order of the superior court for King county vacating an order of adoption entered in another proceeding before the same court. In response to the alternative writ of certiorari, the respondent made and filed his return.

It appears from the record that, on November 16, 1942, the superior court of Washington for King county, probate cause No. 83169 therein, entitled "In the Matter of the Adoption of Rony William Smith, a Minor," made and entered an order authorizing and permitting the petitioners therein named, Theodore H. Eggers and Harriette Eggers, husband and wife, to adopt Rony William Smith, a minor child, and changing his name to Norman Keith Eggers. Prior to this time, the minor had become a ward of the juvenile court and was placed in the temporary custody of Roger Burke and Anne Burke, his wife.

Upon the entry of the order of adoption, the adoptive parents made demand upon the temporary custodians that they deliver the child to them, which demand was refused. On November 17, 1942, the adoptive parents instituted habeas corpus proceedings, and. on that date, a writ of habeas corpus was issued by the superior court of Washington for King county, directed to these custodians, requiring them to bring the child before the court on November 18, 1942.

In response to the writ, the child was brought before the court, and, at the hearing upon the writ of habeas corpus, the court made an order vacating the

 106    STATE EX REL. EGGERS v. MEAKIM.
               Opinion Per GRADY, J.     [16 Wn. (2d)

order of adoption, as shown upon its records by the following minute entry:

     "IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF
          WASHINGTON FOR KING COUNTY
                "Wednesday Nov. 18, 1942
                "Court Convened at 10:15 A. M.
                "Hon. Roger J. Meachim [Meakim]
                                    Presiding
                "Leonard Wilson, Clerk
"No. 340010
"In re: Application of Theodore H. Eggers and
Harriette Eggers for Writ of Habeas Corpus
"Ervin F. Dailey, Atty for Petitioners
"John Caughlan, Atty for Respondents
"Court directs that the Order of Adoption in cause
No. 83169 entered Nov. 16th, 1942, be vacated."

[1] In the return made by the respondent, the adoption proceedings are set forth, from which it appears that the court had jurisdiction to make and enter the order of adoption. This order and the proceedings upon which it is based are fair and regular on their face. In making and entering the order of adoption, we must presume that the court found all the necessary jurisdictional and other facts to exist.

If, at the hearing in the habeas corpus proceedings, it appeared to the court that the order of adoption had been entered without jurisdiction of the court so to do, it would have been justified in disregarding the order. But, as the order was made by a court having jurisdiction so to do, it should have been given full force and effect. The court was without power or authority to summarily vacate the order of adoption at the hearing in the habeas corpus proceedings.

The order before us for review is reversed.

ROBINSON, C. J., BEALS, BLAKE, and SIMPSON, JJ., concur.

Washington Law

Washington State Laws
Washington Court
    > Washington State Courts
Washington Labor Laws
    > Washington State Jobs
Washington State
    > Washington County Jail
Washington Tax
Washington Agencies
    > Washington DMV

Comments

Tips