State Of Washington, Resp- Cross App V. Camano Orion Gahagan, App-cross Resp. (Dissent)

State: Washington

Docket No: 64892-6

Case Date: 01/03/2012

DO NOT CITE. SEE GR 14.1(a).

Court of Appeals Division I
State of Washington

Opinion Information Sheet

Docket Number:	64892-6
Title of Case:	State Of Washington, Resp- Cross App V. Camano Orion Gahagan, App-cross Resp.
File Date:	01/03/2012

SOURCE OF APPEAL
----------------

Appeal from Snohomish Superior Court
Docket No:	09-1-00092-6
Judgment or order under review
Date filed:	01/12/2010
Judge signing:	Honorable Ellen J. Fair

JUDGES
------

Authored by	Linda Lau
Concurring:	J. Robert Leach
Dissenting:	Stephen J. Dwyer

COUNSEL OF RECORD
-----------------

Counsel for Appellant/Cross-Respondent
	Washington Appellate Project
	Attorney at Law
	1511 Third Avenue
	Suite 701
	Seattle, WA, 98101

	Mindy Michelle Carr
	Mindy Carr, Criminal Defense Attorney
	1752 Nw Market St Ste 319
	Seattle, WA, 98107-5264
Counsel for Respondent/Cross-Appellant
	Mary Kathleen Webber
	Snohomish County Prosecutors Office
	Msc 504
	3000 Rockefeller Ave
	Everett, WA, 98201-4061

			

                            STATE v. GAHAGAN, No. 64892-6-I

       DWYER, C.J. (concurring and dissenting)  --  For the reasons set forth in State v. 

Morgan, 163 Wn. App. 341, 348-53, 261 P.3d 167 (2011), I believe that Gahagan 

cannot raise the issue of special verdict instructional error for the first time on appeal.  

Accordingly, I dissent from the majority's holding to the contrary.

       In all other respects, I join in the majority opinion.