State, Res. V. Javon D. Pitchford, App. (Dissent)

State: Washington

Docket No: 65176-5

Case Date: 03/19/2012

DO NOT CITE. SEE GR 14.1(a).

Court of Appeals Division I
State of Washington

Opinion Information Sheet

Docket Number:	65176-5
Title of Case:	State, Res. V. Javon D. Pitchford, App.
File Date:	03/19/2012

SOURCE OF APPEAL
----------------

Appeal from King County Superior Court
Docket No:	08-1-14478-6
Judgment or order under review
Date filed:	04/05/2010
Judge signing:	Honorable Bruce Heller

JUDGES
------

Authored by	Anne Ellington
Concurring:	J. Robert Leach
Dissenting:	Stephen J. Dwyer

COUNSEL OF RECORD
-----------------

Counsel for Appellant(s)
	Washington Appellate Project
	Attorney at Law
	1511 Third Avenue
	Suite 701
	Seattle, WA, 98101

	Elaine L Winters
	Washington Appellate Project
	1511 3rd Ave Ste 701
	Seattle, WA, 98101-3635
Counsel for Respondent(s)
	Prosecuting Atty King County
	King Co Pros/App Unit Supervisor
	W554 King County Courthouse
	516 Third Avenue
	Seattle, WA, 98104

	Ann Marie Summers
	King County Prosecutor's Office
	516 3rd Ave Ste W554
	Seattle, WA, 98104-2362

			

                          State of Washington v. Javon Pitchford
                                        No. 65176-5-I

       Dwyer, C.J. (concurring and dissenting)  --  For the reasons set forth in State v. 

Morgan, 163 Wn. App. 341, 348-53, 261 P.3d 167 (2011), I believe that Pitchford

cannot raise the issue of special verdict instructional error for the first time on appeal.  

Accordingly, I dissent from the majority's holding to the contrary.

       In all other respects, I join in the majority opinion.